Jamaica’s open data programme has advanced further than most of its counterparts in the Caribbean, placing it at the top of most regional rankings. In recent years there have been legislative developments (data protection legislation tabled; open data policy in development), infrastructural developments (portal), as well as capacity building through data training programmes. Despite recent developments, the country has experienced very limited impact from its open data programme thus far. Our analysis found that case studies have illustrated the considerable possibilities and potential value that can be derived from open data, including improved governance, empowered citizens, complex problem-solving, and the creation of new economic opportunities. For Jamaica to extract the benefits offered by open data, more emphasis should be placed on improving data quality and data distribution, as well as on building capacity to use data among the broad spectrum of users. A shift from the status quo is required, to move from a predominantly reactive approach to government institutions releasing data, to one that is generally proactive – released voluntarily and frequently. In addition, there is need for ongoing and systematic collaboration between the GoJ, intermediaries and users, and targeting very specifc issues to be solved by open data.